Optimum vs Xfinity
Comparing two of the most popular internet service providers. See how Optimum and Xfinity stack up on speed, price, coverage, and overall value.
Some products are sponsored. Rankings reflect our honest assessment. See our affiliate disclosure
Quick Answer
Xfinity beats Optimum for most users. Widespread availability across 40+ states. Choose Optimum if you need Fiber speeds up to 8 Gbps.
Optimum
Northeast cable and fiber with fast speeds
Max Download
8.0 Gbps
Max Upload
8.0 Gbps
Starting From
$25/mo
Coverage
4 states
Xfinity
WinnerLargest cable provider with nationwide coverage
Max Download
2.0 Gbps
Max Upload
200 Mbps
Starting From
$40/mo
Coverage
42 states
Speed Comparison
Max Download Speed
Max Upload Speed
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Optimum | Xfinity |
|---|---|---|
| Max Download Speed | 8.0 Gbps | 2.0 Gbps |
| Max Upload Speed | 8.0 Gbps | 200 Mbps |
| Starting Price | $25/mo | $40/mo |
| Data Cap | Unlimited | No overage fees |
| Contract Required | No contract | No contract |
| Coverage | 4 states | 42 states |
| Technologies | Cable, Fiber | Cable, Fiber |
Pros & Cons
Optimum
- Fiber speeds up to 8 Gbps
- No data caps
- No annual contracts
- Free Smart WiFi 6 router
- Competitive pricing
- Strong NYC metro coverage
- Limited to Northeast US
- Fiber availability limited
- Mixed customer service reviews
Xfinity
- Widespread availability across 40+ states
- Speeds up to 2 Gbps in select areas
- Free access to millions of WiFi hotspots
- Bundle discounts with TV and phone
- No annual contracts on most plans
- Reliable network infrastructure
- Price increases after promotional period
- Equipment rental fees add up
- Promo pricing requires 1-year commitment
Our Verdict
With a rating of 8.5/10, Xfinity takes the edge in this comparison with its widespread availability across 40+ states and speeds up to 2 gbps in select areas. However, if fiber speeds up to 8 gbps is more important to you, Optimum is an excellent alternative.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Optimum better than Xfinity?
Xfinity scores higher in our testing (8.5/10 vs 7.9/10). Xfinity excels at widespread availability across 40+ states, while Optimum is better for fiber speeds up to 8 gbps.
Which is cheaper, Optimum or Xfinity?
Optimum is more affordable at $25.00/mo vs $40.00/mo. Optimum offers 38% savings.
Optimum vs Xfinity: which should I choose?
Choose Optimum if you prioritize fiber speeds up to 8 gbps. Choose Xfinity if you need widespread availability across 40+ states. Both are solid internet providers options.
What's the main difference between Optimum and Xfinity?
The main difference is Optimum offers northeast cable and fiber with fast speeds, while Xfinity focuses on largest cable provider with nationwide coverage.