Optimum vs AT&T Fiber
Comparing two of the most popular internet service providers. See how Optimum and AT&T Fiber stack up on speed, price, coverage, and overall value.
Some products are sponsored. Rankings reflect our honest assessment. See our affiliate disclosure
Quick Answer
AT&T Fiber beats Optimum for most users. Symmetrical upload and download speeds. Choose Optimum if you need Fiber speeds up to 8 Gbps.
Optimum
Northeast cable and fiber with fast speeds
Max Download
8.0 Gbps
Max Upload
8.0 Gbps
Starting From
$25/mo
Coverage
4 states
AT&T Fiber
WinnerPremium fiber with symmetrical speeds and no data caps
Max Download
5.0 Gbps
Max Upload
5.0 Gbps
Starting From
$60/mo
Coverage
21 states
Speed Comparison
Max Download Speed
Max Upload Speed
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Optimum | AT&T Fiber |
|---|---|---|
| Max Download Speed | 8.0 Gbps | 5.0 Gbps |
| Max Upload Speed | 8.0 Gbps | 5.0 Gbps |
| Starting Price | $25/mo | $60/mo |
| Data Cap | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Contract Required | No contract | No contract |
| Coverage | 4 states | 21 states |
| Technologies | Cable, Fiber | Fiber |
Pros & Cons
Optimum
- Fiber speeds up to 8 Gbps
- No data caps
- No annual contracts
- Free Smart WiFi 6 router
- Competitive pricing
- Strong NYC metro coverage
- Limited to Northeast US
- Fiber availability limited
- Mixed customer service reviews
AT&T Fiber
- Symmetrical upload and download speeds
- No data caps on any plan
- Speeds up to 5 Gbps available
- Price lock guarantee
- Free equipment included
- Excellent reliability
- Limited availability (21 states)
- Professional installation required
- Higher starting price than cable
Our Verdict
With a rating of 9.1/10, AT&T Fiber takes the edge in this comparison with its symmetrical upload and download speeds and no data caps on any plan. However, if fiber speeds up to 8 gbps is more important to you, Optimum is an excellent alternative.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Optimum better than AT&T Fiber?
AT&T Fiber scores higher in our testing (9.1/10 vs 7.9/10). AT&T Fiber excels at symmetrical upload and download speeds, while Optimum is better for fiber speeds up to 8 gbps.
Which is cheaper, Optimum or AT&T Fiber?
Optimum is more affordable at $25.00/mo vs $60.00/mo. Optimum offers 58% savings.
Optimum vs AT&T Fiber: which should I choose?
Choose Optimum if you prioritize fiber speeds up to 8 gbps. Choose AT&T Fiber if you need symmetrical upload and download speeds. Both are solid internet providers options.
What's the main difference between Optimum and AT&T Fiber?
The main difference is Optimum offers northeast cable and fiber with fast speeds, while AT&T Fiber focuses on premium fiber with symmetrical speeds and no data caps.